These conversations happen to be talking about similar topics, but they're still different people reading and writing different books, and that often results in the ideas being used in different ways. With that, the distinction between fantasy and magic realism is clearer: magic realism authors are those following the magic realism conversation, while fantasy authors are following the fantasy conversation. These are still fantasy, not because they're incorporating fantasy elements, but because they're responding to and inspired by other fantasy books. Guy Kay or Ellen Kushner) that still get counted as fantasy. fantasy books with no, or almost no magic elements (eg. And while the conversation has a topic, that topic can drift - you start out talking about elves and dwarves in a secondary world, and someone starts a tangent about what it'd be like if they were in our world,and so on - hot topics may spin off into being considered seperate conversations completely, and you can sometimes end up quite far from your starting point at the fringes of the conversation - eg.
I think the sole qualifier as to whether you're part of a genre is if you're responding to the works of other writers in that genre. I think a more appropriate metaphor for genre is that of a conversation. Witness the endless bickering about the lines between fantasy, soft SF, and hard SF. TBH, in some ways I think all genre classification is more a cultural artifact than actually determined by hard demarcation rules about the content. I think, to some extent, it's purely a cultural conceit. Urban Fantasy: the magic works with a set magic system (even if it's not a hard magic system) the magic is consistent within the world (as a result of the system) the world in the piece is usually intended to be our world but different Magic realism: there is no magic system the magic in the world can be inconsistent or random, existing only for the events of the story the world in the piece is usually intended to be indiscernable from our world, expect the magicĭo you have any other differentiators you might add? Or what do you think? It's pretty easy to divide magic realism and world-building heavy genres liks sci-fi and fantasy, but it can get hard when it comes down to urban fantasy since both contain elements of magic combined with elements of the real world. Some people who write a fantasy piece and then call it magic realism to make it "fancy" (which was really annoying). But when I started taking a creative writing class outside Latam, I found a lot of people didn't really seem to know the difference between magic realism and other genres. I grew up in Latin America, so magic realism was a part of the curriculum.
0 kommentar(er)
